Listen to this article
Quick summary
- The £36:£1 ROI stat comes from high-performing e-commerce businesses - not average UK SMEs
- Most small businesses achieve 4-6x returns after accounting for platform fees and content creation time
- Hidden costs include £15-35/month per 1,000 subscribers for platforms plus £500+ annually for list hygiene
- Purchased email lists convert at roughly 0.5% versus 2.5%+ for organic sign-ups
- Email beats paid ads for retention but underperforms for cold acquisition
- Most businesses run at a loss for the first six months due to poor segmentation
A client asked me last month: "We keep hearing email returns £36 for every £1 spent. We are spending £800 a month and getting maybe £2,000 back. What are we doing wrong?" The honest answer: probably nothing. That £36 number comes from the DMA's UK Email Benchmarking Report, and it represents a narrow slice of reality - high-performing e-commerce businesses with mature subscriber lists and years of automation behind them.
Most UK businesses under 50 employees will never see 36:1 returns. That does not mean email is broken - it means the headline stat is misleading, and nobody talks about the real numbers.
What actual returns look like for UK SMEs
UK SMEs with fewer than 50 employees typically see 4-6x ROI after six months of consistent list growth and basic segmentation. That improves to 5-8x when you segment by purchase history and engagement signals. Enterprise businesses with 500+ employees often hit 8-10x from day one thanks to integrated CRM data and years of list building.
The gap matters because most marketing advice is written for - and by - the enterprise end of the spectrum. An SME reading "email returns £36 for every £1" and then spending £500/month on a platform, content creation, and list management is going to be disappointed when the revenue doesn't materialise for months.
The costs nobody includes in ROI calculations
Platform fees alone run £15-35 per 1,000 subscribers monthly. Mailchimp, Klaviyo, ActiveCampaign - all charge on a per-subscriber basis that scales with your list. A 10,000-subscriber list costs £150-350/month before you send a single email.
Add list hygiene. Services like ZeroBounce or NeverBounce cost £500-2,000 annually to keep your list clean and your sender reputation intact. Skip this and your deliverability tanks - Google and Yahoo's 2024 sender requirements made this non-optional.
Then there is content creation time. Most businesses spend 12-16 hours weekly on email content without tracking whether those hours convert to revenue. At a conservative £30/hour internal cost, that is £1,440-1,920/month in labour that rarely appears in ROI calculations.
The subscriber quality problem
Businesses that buy email lists or accept low-quality sign-ups through generic lead magnets ("Subscribe to our newsletter!") consistently underperform. Cold purchased lists convert at roughly 0.5% versus 2.5-4.5% for organic sign-ups through specific, problem-solving lead magnets.
A Litmus study found that 72% of businesses still carry at least 20% inactive subscribers in their primary segments. Those inactive addresses do real damage - they increase spam complaint rates, hurt sender reputation scores, and drag down deliverability across every campaign you send.
Worth noting: A list of 5,000 genuinely engaged subscribers will outperform a list of 25,000 mixed-quality addresses on every metric that matters - opens, clicks, conversions, and revenue per email.
When email beats paid ads - and when it doesn't
Email outperforms paid social for retention and repeat purchase campaigns. Businesses using segmented email sequences for existing customers see 20-30% higher repeat purchase rates compared to retargeting ads alone. The cost per conversion is lower because you are reaching people who already know and trust your brand.
But email underperforms for cold acquisition. The cost per new customer through cold email remains 2-3x higher than Facebook or Google lead ads for most B2C businesses. If you are trying to fill the top of your funnel, paid ads still win on cost efficiency.
The signal
Email marketing ROI is real - but it is a retention and loyalty channel, not an acquisition channel. Businesses that treat it as both end up disappointed with overall returns because they are measuring the wrong thing.
Why the first six months lose money
The primary reason businesses report losses in year one is poor list segmentation. Sending the same emails to new subscribers and returning customers produces lower engagement across the board. New subscribers need education and trust building. Returning customers want offers and product updates. Mixing them into one broadcast kills performance for both groups.
Add the cost of content creation without enough data to measure what works, and you are running a negative-ROI operation until your list matures and your segmentation catches up. This is normal - but nobody warns you about it in the "£36 ROI" articles.
Five things to do this month
- Audit your real costs. Add up platform fees, list hygiene tools, and the hours your team spends on email content. Compare that total against attributable email revenue.
- Clean your list. Run a hygiene check with ZeroBounce or NeverBounce. Remove anyone who hasn't opened in 90 days. Your deliverability will improve immediately.
- Fix your lead magnets. Replace generic newsletter sign-ups with specific, problem-solving content. "10 tax deductions UK freelancers miss" converts better than "Subscribe for updates."
- Segment by behaviour. Split your list into at least three groups - new subscribers, active buyers, and lapsed customers. Send different content to each.
- Build a win-back sequence. Set up a three-email automated sequence for subscribers inactive for 60+ days. Offer a discount or free resource. This alone can recover 10-15% of lapsed subscribers.
Email marketing works. The ROI is real for businesses that approach it with realistic expectations and track the full cost picture. The £36:£1 headline is not a lie - it is just not your number yet. Getting there takes six to twelve months of disciplined list building, segmentation, and honest cost accounting.